Online vs. In-Store Mattress Shopping

Last Updated January 10, 2025

Purchasing a new mattress is not a small decision. Your comfort, health, and overall sleep quality depend on selecting the right one. The rise of online shopping has made things more complicated, giving buyers a choice between traditional in-store visits and the convenience of online platforms. Both ways have their own sets of pros and cons, and knowing these differences is key to making a smart choice. Come, let's dig deeper into the topic and help you figure out the best way to go.

Key Takeaways:

  • Physically trying mattresses allows for hands-on evaluation and personalized assistance from sales staff.
  • In-store shopping can be overwhelming, time-consuming, and often comes with higher prices.
  • Online shopping offers flexibility, allowing customers to browse a wide selection from anywhere at lower prices.
  • Online retailers provide more mattress options and extended sleep trials for evaluation at home.
  • Access to reviews and expert opinions online helps shoppers make informed choices.
Online vs. In-store Mattress

The Traditional In-Store Mattress Experience

Shopping for a mattress in a physical store has been the go-to method for years. It’s hard to beat the tactile experience of lying down on a mattress before buying it. You get to see, feel, and test different options while receiving guidance from sales staff who know their stuff.

The Traditional In-Store Mattress Experience

Pros of In-Store Mattress Shopping

Let's look at the many benefits of buying a mattress in-store.

  • Immediate Testing

One key advantage of shopping in-store is the ability to test the mattresses physically. By lying on each one, you can directly feel the firmness, pressure relief, and overall comfort. This hands-on experience is important to see how the mattress will feel during sleep, especially if you have specific needs, such as back pain relief or a preference for a particular firmness level.

  • Personalized Guidance

Buying in-store means you get to talk to knowledgeable sales staff who can give you personalized advice based on your sleep preferences. These experts are well-versed in different types of mattresses, including latex, innerspring, memory foam, and hybrid models, and can help guide you to the best option based on your specific needs.

For example, if you have chronic back pain, a sales associate can recommend mattresses with targeted support or pressure-relieving materials. If you're concerned about sleeping hot, they can suggest mattresses with cooling properties. This tailored advice helps ensure you make a well-informed decision.

  • Hassle-Free Delivery

Many mattress stores offer delivery and setup services, often included in the purchase price. This convenience ensures that your new mattress is transported to your home, placed in the desired location, and ready for use.

Some stores even provide the added service of removing your old mattress, saving you the hassle of dealing with mattress disposal. This seamless delivery process can significantly reduce the stress of purchasing a mattress and make the transition to your new bed smoother.

  • Negotiation Opportunities

In-store shopping often offers the opportunity to negotiate. Salespeople may be willing to adjust the price, offer discounts, or provide added perks to close the deal. You may also be able to secure additional benefits like free delivery, an extended warranty, or complimentary accessories such as mattress protectors or pillows.

Discussing terms face-to-face makes it easier for you to customize your purchase, which can enhance the overall value of the transaction.

latex mattress

Cons of In-Store Mattress Shopping

While in-store mattress shopping offers several advantages, there are also some downsides to consider. Being aware of these drawbacks can help you make a well-rounded decision:

  • Limited Options

Physical stores often carry a limited selection of mattresses due to space constraints. As a result, you may not have access to the full range of mattress types, materials, or brands available. This limitation may prevent you from exploring niche options or newer models that could better suit your needs. Stores generally stock the most popular or high-demand mattresses, which means some specialized or custom mattresses may not be available for testing.

  • Time-Consuming

In-store mattress shopping can be time-intensive. If you visit multiple stores to explore different options and compare prices, it can become exhausting. Navigating between different locations, testing various models, and gathering information may take several hours or even an entire day, depending on how many stores you visit.

  • Sales Pressure

Sometimes, in-store mattress shopping comes with the pressure to make a purchase quickly. Sales associates may encourage you to make a decision on the spot, which can lead to feelings of stress or urgency. This pressure to close a sale can interfere with your ability to thoroughly evaluate your options or take the time needed to make a thoughtful decision. As a result, you may end up purchasing a mattress in haste, only to later realize it doesn’t meet all of your needs.

  • Higher Costs

The overhead costs associated with running a brick-and-mortar store, such as rent, utilities, and staffing, may contribute to slightly higher mattress prices. These extra costs can add up and might not always fit your budget. Some stores may have sales or promotions, but the prices can still be higher than those of other ways of buying.

The Rise of Online Mattress Shopping

In recent years, online mattress shopping has transformed how people buy beds. The convenience of browsing from home, coupled with advancements in e-commerce, has made this method increasingly popular. As of 2024, the e-commerce mattress market is valued at an impressive $15 billion, accounting for 23% of the total global mattress market, a testament to the rapid shift in consumer preferences towards online shopping.

Online mattress shopping experience

Pros of Online Mattress Shopping

There are several compelling advantages to shopping for a mattress online. Here’s a deeper look into these benefits:

  • Unmatched Convenience

One primary reason people turn to online mattress shopping is the ease of purchasing from home, 24/7.

Whether you're browsing late at night after work or during a lunch break, there are no restrictions on time. This flexibility is  valuable for individuals with busy or irregular schedules, as it eliminates the need to coordinate visits to physical stores.

Plus, you can shop at your own pace without being rushed by salespeople or limited by store hours, which makes the whole experience much more relaxed and fun.

  • Wider Selection

Online mattress stores offer many choices you might not find in regular stores. You can shop for specific brands, unique mattress types like hybrids, latex, or foam, and even hard-to-find sizes.

It’s easy to narrow down your options by filtering for things like firmness, material, or price. Since online stores don’t have the same space limits as physical stores, they can offer a wide variety, from affordable options to high-end luxury mattresses, to suit different needs and budgets.

  • Extended Sleep Trials

Another standout feature of online mattress shopping is the extended sleep trials that many companies offer. These trials can range from 30 days to an entire year, allowing you to test the mattress in the comfort of your own home. This extended period gives you ample time to assess whether the mattress truly meets your needs.

The ability to live with the mattress and make an informed decision without being rushed is a unique advantage when compared to the limited time spent testing mattresses in a store.

  • Cost-Effective

Online mattress shopping is a cost-effective option as it eliminates the expenses associated with physical stores, sales staff, and middlemen. This allows mattress retailers to offer lower prices, along with frequent discounts, promotions, and seasonal sales. As a result, shoppers can often find high-quality mattresses at more affordable prices than in traditional brick-and-mortar stores. This makes online shopping a great choice for budget-conscious buyers or anyone looking to get the best value for their money.

  • Access to Reviews

One of the most valuable tools in online mattress shopping is the wealth of customer feedback and expert reviews. With just a few clicks, shoppers can access detailed reviews and ratings from other buyers, which can provide insight into the mattress's overall quality.

Many online retailers also feature comparison tools that allow you to examine different models side by side, highlighting key features and benefits. This abundance of information helps you make a more informed decision.

Cons of Online Mattress Shopping

Despite its many advantages, buying a mattress online comes with a few drawbacks. Here are some challenges that consumers may face:

  • Lack of Physical Testing

One downside of buying a mattress online is that you can’t physically test it before making a purchase. While descriptions and pictures can provide helpful details, they don’t replace the experience of lying on the mattress to feel its firmness and comfort. This can make it harder for some people to choose with confidence and may lead to uncertainty about whether the mattress will meet their expectations once it’s delivered.

  • Return Logistics

If the mattress doesn't meet your expectations, returning it can be more complicated than simply bringing it back to a store. Depending on the retailer, the return procedure may require extra steps, such as arranging for the mattress to be picked up or donated. Some online brands even charge return fees or do not offer full refunds.

The mattress can also take up a lot of space, making it harder to handle, particularly if you need to dispose of it yourself. This extra hassle might discourage customers who prefer a simpler return process or are hesitant about the commitment.

  • Delivery Delays

A common drawback of online mattress shopping is the potential for delivery delays, which can range from a few days to several weeks. Customers who need a mattress urgently, such as when moving into a new home or replacing a damaged one, may find this particularly inconvenient. While many retailers offer free shipping, delivery schedules might not always align with your needs, and unexpected delays can add to the frustration.

  • Overwhelming Choices

The abundance of options available online may lead to decision fatigue, leaving consumers feeling overwhelmed by the sheer variety. With so many features, brands, and models to consider, finding the right mattress for your needs can feel like a daunting task. Shoppers may struggle to make a choice or become confused by the differences between similar models, especially when they can’t physically test the mattress beforehand.

Key Considerations When Buying a Mattress: Online vs. In-Store

Now that you're aware of the advantages and drawbacks of purchasing a mattress online versus in-store, here are some essential factors to help you make the right choice for your needs:

1. Comfort and Firmness Preferences

Choosing a mattress based on comfort and firmness preferences

Comfort is the top priority when choosing a mattress. Since everyone's firmness preference differs, it's important to consider your sleeping position. Side sleepers generally prefer soft mattresses for better pressure relief on the hips and shoulders. Back sleepers benefit from medium-firm options that offer proper spinal alignment. Stomach sleepers often find firm mattresses more supportive, preventing excessive sinking.

2. Material and Construction

Choosing a mattress based on material and construction

The materials in a mattress directly affect its comfort and longevity. Memory foam molds to your body for pressure relief but can trap heat, so look for models with cooling features if you're prone to overheating. Innerspring mattresses, known for their support and bounce, tend to be cooler. Hybrid mattresses combine foam and coils, offering the best of both worlds. Latex options are naturally cool, durable, and hypoallergenic, ideal for those with sensitivities. Always make sure to choose mattresses made with high-quality materials that best suit your comfort needs and sleep habits.

3. Health Considerations

Choosing a mattress based on health considerations

Health issues like back pain or allergies require special attention when choosing a mattress. For back pain, look for a mattress that promotes spinal alignment and prevents excessive sinking. Those with allergies should opt for hypoallergenic materials, such as latex, which resist dust mites. If you tend to sleep hot, seek mattresses with cooling technology like breathable fabrics or gel-infused foam.

4. Size

Choosing a mattress based on size

Selecting the right mattress size is crucial for a comfortable sleep setup. If you sleep alone, a full or queen mattress might be sufficient. Couples or those who prefer extra space should consider a king or California king. Ensure the mattress fits well in your bedroom, allowing room for other furniture and easy movement. A mattress that's too large can overwhelm a small room, while one that's too small may not offer adequate space.

5. Budget

Choosing a mattress based on budget

Your budget will influence your mattress choice. While premium models typically offer superior materials and longer-lasting comfort, there are plenty of affordable options without compromising quality. Online stores often feature discounts, making it easier to find a great deal. In-store options can also be on sale, but online retailers may offer better prices or more flexible return policies. Aim for a mattress that fits within your budget while meeting your essential comfort requirements.

6. Warranty and Trial Period

Choosing a mattress based on warranty and trial period

A solid warranty and trial period provide peace of mind with your purchase. Many online retailers offer trial periods, allowing you to test the mattress in your home for up to 100 days. If you're unsatisfied, you can return it for a refund. Furthermore, check the warranty details for coverage on defects or premature wear to ensure you're protected in the long run.

7. Delivery and Setup

Choosing a mattress based on delivery and setup

Consider the delivery and setup process before making a purchase. In-store shopping requires you to arrange delivery, which could incur extra fees. Many in-store retailers offer "white-glove" service, where the mattress is delivered and set up for you, and your old mattress is removed. Online stores often provide free delivery and may offer similar setup services, but delivery times can vary, so it's wise to confirm the estimated arrival date.

8. Customer Reviews and Brand Reputation

Choosing a mattress based on customer reviews and brand reputation

Before committing to a mattress, read customer reviews to gauge its comfort, durability, and overall quality. Reviews often highlight any possible issues, giving you a clearer picture of what to expect. Also, make sure to research the brand's reputation for customer service and product quality. A trusted company is more likely to provide a satisfying shopping experience and responsive support if any issues arise.

9. Environmental Impact

Choosing a mattress based on environmental impact

If environmental sustainability is important to you, look for mattresses made from eco-friendly materials like organic cotton or natural latex. These materials are not only better for the planet but are also free from harmful chemicals. Many mattresses are certified by organizations such as OEKO-TEX, GOLS, and GOTS, ensuring they’re made without toxic substances. Choosing a sustainable mattress can help minimize your environmental footprint.

Making the Right Choice: Online vs. In-Store

A person confused betwenn online and in-store mattress purchase

If you’re someone who values convenience and saving a bit of money, shopping online is the way to go. But if you prefer being able to test things out and get personalized advice, an in-store experience could offer the reassurance you need.

Think about your schedule and how much time you have. If you're busy or live far from any stores, online shopping can save you a lot of hassle. Plus, it’s easier to find product details and read customer reviews online, which can help you make an informed decision.

On the other hand, if you have specific needs, such as medical conditions that require a certain level of support, shopping in a store might be more comfortable. Trying out the mattress firsthand can give you peace of mind and help you avoid returns.

Here’s a simple approach to help you decide:

  • Start Online: Begin by doing some research. Look at reviews and compare options to narrow down your choices. This way, you’re not starting from scratch when you visit a store (if you decide to).
  • Visit a Store: Once you have a few options in mind, it might help to test them out in person. This gives you the best of both worlds—doing your homework online but still getting that hands-on experience to make sure the mattress feels right.
  • Know Your Needs: If you have particular requirements, like needing a mattress for back pain, talking to someone in-store can be really helpful. But if you're tech-savvy and comfortable with online research, you might feel more confident making your decision without stepping foot in a store.

In the end, it’s all about what’s most important to you—whether that’s the ease of online shopping or the certainty of testing things out in person.

natural and organic latex mattress topper

The Bottom Line

Both online and in-store mattress shopping have their merits and drawbacks. Online platforms cater to the tech-savvy and budget-conscious, while traditional stores appeal to those who prefer hands-on evaluation and personal interaction.

As the mattress market evolves, it’s clear that there’s no one-size-fits-all solution. Your choice will depend on factors like convenience, budget, and comfort needs. But at the end of the day, your mission is the same: find a mattress that makes you feel like you’re floating on a cloud.

Remember, investing in the right mattress is an investment in your health and well-being. So, take your time, weigh the options, and pick the one that will give you restful sleep for years to come—because if you’re well-rested, you’ll probably be way more productive… or at least better at napping.

natural and organic pillows

FAQs

1. What is the average cost difference between online and in-store mattresses?

Online mattresses tend to be 15-20% cheaper compared to their in-store counterparts. This cost difference arises because online retailers don’t have the same overhead expenses, like rent and staffing, as brick-and-mortar stores.

For budget-conscious buyers, this price gap makes online mattress shopping a compelling option without compromising on variety or quality.

2. Can I negotiate prices when buying a mattress online?

Negotiating prices isn’t typical in online mattress shopping, as most platforms operate on fixed pricing models. However, online retailers frequently offer discounts, seasonal sales, and promotional codes that can significantly lower the cost.

Signing up for newsletters or following brands on social media can alert you to special offers. Though direct haggling isn’t typical, these promotions often yield savings similar to in-store negotiations.

3. Are online sleep trials reliable?

Online sleep trials are reliable and designed to give you a risk-free opportunity to test the mattress. Most brands offer trials ranging from 30 days to a full year, ensuring ample time to determine if the mattress meets your needs.

If dissatisfied, you can return the mattress for a refund, although some brands may require you to donate or dispose of it locally. These trials reflect online retailers' confidence in their products.

4. Do in-store purchases come with better warranties?

Warranty terms are consistent across both online and in-store purchases, as they depend on the manufacturer rather than the shopping method.

In some cases, in-store purchases may come with added perks, such as extended warranties or protection plans offered by the retailer.

Regardless of where you buy, always read the fine print to understand what is covered, including exclusions and claim procedures, to ensure peace of mind. Warranty terms depend on the brand, not the shopping method. Check specifics before purchasing.

5. What should I prioritize when choosing between online and in-store shopping?

Prioritize factors that align with your personal needs and circumstances. If convenience, lower costs, and extended sleep trials matter most, online shopping is ideal. For those who value tactile evaluation and personalized advice, in-store shopping is better.

Ultimately, the goal is to find a mattress that promotes restful sleep and fits seamlessly into your lifestyle. Focus on your personal needs—whether it’s convenience, cost, or hands-on testing.

6. Can I trust mattress reviews when buying online?

Yes, but be sure to read multiple reviews from verified customers. Look for trends in feedback regarding comfort, durability, and customer service. Independent review sites and forums can also provide unbiased opinions.

7. Are there any disadvantages to buying a mattress online?

The main downside is that you cannot physically try the mattress. Additionally, returns or exchanges can be more complicated than in-store shopping. Depending on the retailer, shipping delays or complications could also be an issue.

8. How to choose the best online mattress?

Start by identifying your sleep needs, such as your preferred position and any specific issues like back pain. Choose a material—memory foam for contouring, latex for durability, or hybrid for versatility—and a firmness level that suits your body type. Check for safety certifications and review trial periods, return policies, and warranties. Reading reviews and setting a budget that balances quality and cost can also help you make the right choice.

9. How to make your softer online mattress firm?

To firm up a soft mattress, use a high-density foam or latex mattress topper and place it on a solid base like a platform bed. Cooler room temperatures can also firm up memory foam. Rotate or flip the mattress to even out wear, or add plywood between the mattress and bed frame for extra support. If still unsatisfied, consider exchanging it for a firmer option within the trial period.

Related blog posts:

1. When Is the Best Time to Buy a Mattress?

When Is the Best Time to Buy a Mattress?

2. How Often Should You Replace Your Mattress?

How often should you replace your mattress

3. Is Amazon the Best Place to Buy Mattresses?

Is Amazon the Best Place to Buy Mattresses?

4. How Much Does a Mattress Cost?

How Much Does a Mattress Cost?

5. Mattress Glossary

Mattress Glossary

Disclaimer: What is said in this article has been referenced from multiple sources and is intended only for educational and informational purposes. Please note that no content in this article is a substitute for professional advice from a qualified doctor or healthcare provider. Always consult an experienced doctor with any concerns you may have regarding a health condition or treatment, and never disregard any medical suggestions or delay in seeking treatment because of something you read here.

BACK TO TOP
x